Jurewicz v. U.S. Dep't of Agric.
November 22, 2012
Missouri dog breeders sued the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) to prevent the release of business information to the Humane Society. The Humane Society had filed a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request in 2009 and the USDA made the decision to release the information in March, 2011. At that point, the Missouri dog breeders sued in a reverse FOIA action to prevent the release of the information.
The business information (known as block 8 from the form in which it is filed with the USDA) consists of: "(1) the total number of animals purchased and sold in the last year; (2) the gross revenue from regulated activities; and (3) for dealers that are not breeders, the difference between the purchase price and sale price of the animals sold."
The only trade secrets issue raised was 5 U.S.C.A. § 552b(c)(4) (West), which forbids an agency from releasing information that is "trade secrets and commercial or financial information obtained from a person that is privileged or confidential." This exemption is broader than the definition of trade secrets under UTSA or the common law. But once the USDA had determined that it could release the information, the agency's decision was subject only to arbitrary or capricious review by the court. The court noted that 1) Humane Society is not a competitor of the dog breeders, 2) that the information was stale and incomplete, and 3) that release would not significantly assist competitors in gauging the scale of a licensee’s operation because similar information was already in the public domain.
Carolyn Jurewicz, Hunte Corporation, Missouri Pet Breeders Association, Sharon Lavy
Humane Society of the United States, USDA